1700s MYSTERIOUS Button Discovered in Stone—Cursed Treasure Clue? | The Curse of Oak Island

The Mystery Deepens: Oak Island’s Lot Five Reveals Key Discovery That Could Unlock Hidden Treasures

For over 200 years, Oak Island has captured the imagination of treasure hunters, adventurers, and archaeologists alike. The legend of a buried treasure—possibly hidden by pirates, Freemasons, or even British naval officers—has fueled endless searches, many of which have yielded only fragments of history. But the island’s allure is undeniable. From cryptic symbols to strange underground structures, Oak Island continues to spark the belief that great riches lie hidden beneath its soil. Despite decades of effort, no one has yet uncovered the elusive treasure, but recent discoveries are bringing the island’s secrets to light, one piece at a time.

One such discovery, made on Lot Five, could very well be the key to unlocking Oak Island’s long-standing mystery. Lot Five, located on the western side of Oak Island, has been a quiet enigma for many years. Previously overlooked in the hunt for treasure, it has recently begun to reveal surprising artifacts that may change everything. These discoveries not only date back centuries, but they also seem to tie the island to some of the most intriguing historical figures and events. What was once an overlooked patch of land has become one of the most mysterious sites on Oak Island, and the latest find may hold the answers treasure hunters have been waiting for.

A Game-Changing Discovery

The journey to uncover hidden treasure on Oak Island is a slow and careful process. It involves painstaking work, an eye for detail, and a bit of luck. The team at Oak Island, led by Rick Lagina, Gary Drayton, archaeologist Fiona Steel, and the rest of the crew, has spent years sifting through the island’s history in search of clues. Every beep from their metal detectors could indicate something monumental, and as anyone who’s followed the Oak Island mystery knows, the search requires a delicate balance of excitement and caution. The recent discovery on Lot Five has certainly generated a great deal of both.

Gary Drayton, the island’s expert metal detectorist, was working near an old stone structure when he heard an unusual beep from his detector. Initially, he thought it was just another common find—a piece of iron or a stray nail. But as he continued scanning, the signal became clearer and sharper. This was no ordinary beep. It was a non-ferrous metal signal, indicating that the object buried beneath the earth could be something far more significant—copper, brass, silver, or even gold.

Non-ferrous metals, unlike iron, don’t rust and are often used in valuable objects, especially those that are intentionally hidden. As the team moved in to investigate further, the excitement in the air was palpable. They carefully began excavating the area, knowing that every movement of soil, every piece of rock, and every layer of earth could reveal a hidden clue. This was no ordinary find; the object was embedded deep within the stonework itself, suggesting that it had been deliberately placed there—and deliberately sealed away.

Unveiling the Button

The careful excavation soon led to the unearthing of a small, round metallic object. It wasn’t a coin or another scrap of metal, but a button. However, this was no ordinary button. Upon closer inspection, it became clear that this button was intricate, ornate, and highly detailed, suggesting it was a piece of fine craftsmanship. The button had a raised outer rim and a beautifully pressed design that didn’t match the typical buttons of the time.

At first, the team couldn’t determine exactly what the pattern was, but one thing was clear: This was not a simple button from a worker’s coat. It was far more refined, more purposeful. It was a button made for someone of importance. The craftsmanship and care that went into its design raised an immediate question: Who owned this button? What was its purpose? And how did it end up sealed inside this mysterious stone structure?

The button’s design and the larger loop on its back suggested it had been part of a heavy garment—possibly a jacket or uniform. It wasn’t an everyday item but rather something that had once belonged to someone of significance. This discovery wasn’t just another random artifact; it was a carefully placed object, and the team began to wonder whether it could be linked to one of the most famous theories surrounding Oak Island’s treasure—the lost wealth of Sir William Phips.

The Sir William Phips Connection

Sir William Phips was a British sea captain who gained fame in the late 1600s for leading an expedition to recover treasure from the wrecked Spanish galleon Concepción. The ship, which sank off the coast of the Dominican Republic, was rumored to be carrying an extraordinary fortune in silver and gold. Phips and his crew successfully recovered a vast treasure from the wreck, estimated to be between 30 and 40 tons of precious metals. However, when Phips returned to England, only a portion of the treasure was officially recorded as recovered.

This missing portion of treasure has been the subject of intense speculation for centuries. Some historians believe that Phips, aided by trusted allies, secretly diverted a portion of the treasure and stored it in a hidden location, possibly on Oak Island. The timing and composition of the ornate button found on Lot Five fits perfectly with this theory. If the button dates back to the late 1600s or early 1700s, it could very well have belonged to a member of Phips’ crew—or even Phips himself.

The button’s age, material, and design all align with the time period of Phips’ treasure expedition, making it a strong candidate to be part of the missing treasure. The fact that the button was sealed inside a stone structure suggests that it was hidden intentionally, either as part of a larger construction project or as a marker for something valuable. If this button is indeed connected to Phips or one of his men, it could be a tangible piece of evidence linking Oak Island to the long-lost treasure of the Concepción.

Further Analysis: Confirming the Button’s Origin

The team wasted no time in sending the button to the Oak Island lab for further analysis. Archaeometallurgist Emma Culligan and her team used advanced technology, such as X-ray fluorescence (XRF) scanning, to determine the button’s composition and age. This non-destructive method allowed them to analyze the metal without causing any damage to the artifact. The results showed that the button is made from a copper alloy, typical of brass used in the late 1600s to early 1700s. This finding further supports the theory that the button dates back to the period of Phips’ treasure expedition.

The button’s intricate design was also examined in greater detail. The XRF scan revealed fine engravings beneath the layers of corrosion, showing a delicate floral pattern. While these details were previously obscured, the scan allowed the team to enhance the image and reveal the button’s true design. This pattern was not just decorative but could signify something more important—such as a specific military regiment, merchant guild, or social rank. The design and craftsmanship suggest that this was a button worn by someone of importance, possibly a member of the British navy or military.

Linking Oak Island to Hidden Treasures

The discovery of the ornate button has brought new life to one of Oak Island’s most famous theories: the connection between the island and the missing treasure of Sir William Phips. If the button was indeed part of a naval or military uniform, it raises significant questions. Was the stone structure on Lot Five built by Phips’ men, or could it have been used to store or protect the treasure they had recovered? With the button’s age and design matching that of British naval uniforms from the late 1600s, the team is now more convinced than ever that Oak Island played a crucial role in the story of the missing treasure.

The idea that Oak Island may have been used as a covert site for storing treasure or hiding valuable items is gaining credibility. Other artifacts found on Lot Five, including iron tools, have been linked to the same time period, further strengthening the theory that the island was a location of great historical significance. As the team continues their excavation, each new discovery provides more clues about Oak Island’s role in the events surrounding the Concepción treasure.

The Search Continues

With the discovery of the button, the mystery of Oak Island becomes even more compelling. The button could be the key to unraveling a much larger story, one that links the island to one of the greatest treasure recoveries of the 17th century. As the team digs deeper, they are hopeful that more artifacts will surface, each one adding another piece to the puzzle. The possibility of hidden wealth on Oak Island is still very much alive, and the team is more determined than ever to uncover the truth.

As they continue to follow the clues left behind by those who came before, the search for Oak Island’s hidden treasure continues. Every new discovery brings them one step closer to unraveling the island’s long-standing mystery, and the button found on Lot Five may just be the key that unlocks the secrets of Oak Island for good.

Stay tuned as the mystery unfolds, and don’t forget to like, share, and subscribe to keep up with the latest developments in the search for Oak Island’s treasure. The adventure is far from over, and the truth may be just around the corner.