1700s MYSTERIOUS Button Discovered in Stone—Cursed Treasure Clue? | The Curse of Oak Island

The Mysterious Button of Oak Island: A Breakthrough Discovery on Lot Five

Oak Island has long been a site of intrigue, with tales of buried treasure, centuries-old legends, and the relentless pursuit of answers driving countless expeditions over the years. While stories of pirate gold and lost riches have sparked the imagination of treasure hunters for over two centuries, it is the physical clues that continue to bring people back to this mysterious island. Among the many locations on Oak Island, Lot Five is one of the most enigmatic and has become a focal point for some of the island’s most extraordinary discoveries.

Located on the island’s western side, Lot Five had remained largely overlooked for years. However, recent excavations have uncovered artifacts that are far older than the search itself, including trade beads from the 1600s and tools that might be linked to Sir William Phips, the British sea captain thought to have hidden Spanish treasure on the island. But the most recent discovery on Lot Five could be the most significant yet—a delicate, ornate button, hidden deep within the stonework of a mysterious structure.

A Metal Detection Breakthrough

The discovery began with a familiar signal—a beep from a metal detector. While metal detection is an everyday part of the search on Oak Island, this beep was different. Gary Dron, the metal detection expert, was standing over the mysterious stone structure when his detector emitted a sharp, non-ferrous signal. Unlike the usual scrap metal or iron signals, this beep indicated the presence of valuable materials such as copper, brass, silver, or gold.

Gary and the rest of the team immediately sensed they might be onto something important. As they carefully dug into the stone structure, the team discovered that the object was not simply buried in the dirt; it was embedded within the wall itself, suggesting that it had been deliberately hidden away. This find was different from anything they had previously encountered on Oak Island.

Uncovering the Button

As the team meticulously excavated the area around the signal, Jack Begley was the first to notice something small and metallic peeking through the soil. With great care, he lifted it out and gently brushed off the dirt. It was a button—ornate, with a raised outer rim and an intricate, floral design. The craftsmanship of the button immediately stood out; this was no ordinary item. It was a button designed for someone of importance.

The button’s larger-than-usual loop suggested that it was meant to be sewn onto something durable, possibly a jacket or coat, and not a simple work garment. The design, which appeared to be a delicate floral pattern, added to the button’s uniqueness. After further examination, the team realized the button’s design and composition could help pinpoint its origin.

Scientific Analysis: What Does the Button Tell Us?

To determine the true age and origin of the button, the team took it to the Oak Island lab for further analysis. Using x-ray fluorescence (XRF) scanning, the team examined the button’s metal composition. The results revealed a high concentration of copper with traces of zinc and tin, materials typical of brass used in the late 1600s and early 1700s.

The findings aligned with the time period when Sir William Phips, a British captain and later the governor of Massachusetts, led an expedition to recover treasure from the wreck of the Spanish galleon Conception in 1687. The treasure recovered was said to consist of a vast amount of silver and gold, but historical records suggest that not all of it made it back to England. Some believe that a portion of the treasure was secretly diverted and hidden elsewhere—possibly on Oak Island.

A Link to Sir William Phips and the Missing Treasure

The timing of the button’s creation fits perfectly within the window of Phips’ treasure expedition. The discovery of the button on Lot Five raises a compelling possibility: Was it part of the treasure hidden on Oak Island by Phips or his crew? If so, the button could provide a key piece of evidence linking the island to the missing wealth of the Conception.

The location of the button is equally intriguing. Unlike random surface finds, this button was deliberately placed inside a stone structure, further suggesting that it was hidden with intent. Theories surrounding the Freemason connection to Oak Island also gain traction, with some suggesting that Freemasons may have played a role in the treasure’s concealment.

Theories and Questions Moving Forward

As the team continues to analyze the button and the surrounding area, more questions arise. Was the stone structure on Lot Five built by Phips’ men? Could this be part of a larger hidden treasure hoard still buried on the island? The find reinforces the theory that Oak Island was used as a hidden storage site for valuable items, and it adds weight to the idea that Phips’ expedition may have left behind more than just a few scattered clues.

The discovery of this 17th-century button on Oak Island is not just another random artifact. It is a tangible link to the past, one that raises the stakes for the ongoing search. As more evidence is gathered, the mystery of Oak Island continues to unfold. The button, with its intricate design and historical significance, is a crucial clue that could unlock secrets that have remained buried for centuries.

The team now faces the exciting challenge of further excavation and research. With each discovery, the puzzle pieces are slowly coming together, and Oak Island’s legendary treasure may be closer than ever to being uncovered. The search continues, and with it, the hope that one day the full truth of what happened on Oak Island will finally be revealed.

Stay tuned, as the mystery of Oak Island is far from over, and every new discovery brings the team one step closer to solving one of the world’s most captivating treasure hunts.